Football: who's back? A quick look at IU's 2008 and 2009 depth charts.
As I said last week, now that football season will be upon us in less than two months, I plan to begin the preview process. I won't make any schedule guarantees, because those quickly become broken promises, but you can expect to see the following: first, today's post, a big picture look at how the depth chart changed last season from the season opener (Western Kentucky) to the conference opener (Michigan State) to the season/conference finale (Purdue) and to spring practice this year. When we get closer to the season and after fall practice begins, I'll take a unit-by-unit look at IU's returning players and newcomers. In the meantime, I plan to take a look at all of IU's 2009 opponents and, as painful as it will be compared to the last two years, a game-by-game look at the 12-car pileup that was the 2008 IU football season.
The chart below gives a depth chart snapshot of IU's 2008 season at various points and compares it to the 2009 spring depth chart. The 2009 chart is not an official IU release, but is a combination of IU's spring depth chart and the published list of "returning starters" from IU's spring release. Unlike the official spring depth chart, it includes guys such as Will Patterson and Nick Polk who missed spring practice but will be back, hopefully, in the fall. It's not really a prediction, but is more of a rough outline of where the roster stands as fall practice approaches:
| POS | Western Ky. | Mich. St. | Purdue | 2009? |
|
OFFENSE |
||||
| LT | Roger Saffold | Saffold | Saffold | Saffold |
| Andrew McDonald | McDonald | Josh Hager | McDonald | |
| LG | Pete Saxon | Saxon | Justin Pagan | Pagan |
| Jarrod Smith | Smith | Mike Reiter | Marc Damisch | |
| C | Alex Perry | Perry | Saxon | Saxon |
| Jarrod Smith | Mike Reiter | Smith | Perry | |
| RG | Cody Faulkner | Faulkner | Faulkner | Faulkner |
| Dennis Ziegler | Ziegler | Smith | Reiter | |
| RT | Mike Stark | Stark | Stark | Brewer |
| James Brewer | Brewer | Perry | Josh Hager | |
| WR | Terrence Turner | Turner | Turner | Turner |
| Matt Ernest | DaMarlo Belcher | Belcher | Belcher | |
| WR | Andrew Means | Means | Means | Evans |
| Mitchell Evans | Evans | Tandon Doss | Ernest | |
| WR | Ray Fisher | Fisher | Fisher | Doss |
| Brandon Walker-Roby | Walker-Roby | Walker-Roby | Chris Banks | |
| QB | Kellen Lewis | Lewis | Lewis | Chappell |
| Ben Chappell | Chappell | Chappell | Teddy Schell | |
| Mitchell Evans | Adam Follett | |||
| RB | Marcus Thigpen | Thigpen | Thigpen | Payton |
| Bryan Payton | Payton | McCray | McCray | |
| Demetrius McCray | McCray | Darius Willis | Willis | |
| TE | Brad Martin | Troy Wagner | Wagner | Wagner |
| Max Dedmond | Brad Martin | Dedmond | Dedmond | |
|
DEFENSE |
||||
| LE | Jammie Kirlew | Kirlew | Kirlew | Middleton |
| Ryan Marando | Marando | Marando | Terrence Thomas | |
| DT | Deonte Mack | Burrus | Mack | Mack |
| Keith Burrus | Mack | Burrus | Nicholas Sliger | |
| DT | Greg Brown | Brown | Brown | Jarrod Smith |
| Keith Burrus | Burrus | Burrus | Mick Mentzer | |
| RE | Greg Middleton | Middleton | Middleton | Kirlew |
| Fred Jones | Jones | Eric Thomas | Thomas | |
| WLB | Will Patterson | Patterson | Patterson | Patterson |
| Justin Carrington | Carrington | Replogle | Carrington | |
| MLB | Matt Mayberry | Mayberry | Mayberry | Mayberry |
| Tyler Replogle | Replogle | Replogle | Darius Johnson | |
| SLB | Geno Johnson | Johnson | Johnson | Replogle |
| Darius Johnson | Johnson | Johnson | Trea Burgess | |
| CB | Christopher Phillips | Council | Donnell Jones | Ray Fisher |
| Richard Council | Adrian Burks | Burks | Council | |
| FS | Nick Polk | Kleinsmith | Moseley | Polk |
| Joe Kleinsmith | Brandon Moseley | Colin Taylor | Finch | |
| SS | Austin Thomas | Thomas | Kleinsmith | Thomas |
| Jerimy Finch | Finch | Jarrell Drane | Drane | |
| CB | Chris Adkins | Adkins | Adkins | Adkins |
| Donnell Jones | Andre LeGrone | LeGrone | Jones |
What does this tell us?
Looking at the snapshots of the season doesn't provide the entire story about injuries. Still, the chart does make clear that the secondary and the left side of the offensive line bore the brunt of the season-ending injuries last season. On the other hand, the offensive skill positions, the defensive line, and the linebacking corps held up reasonably well, although there were injuries of shorter duration that I will discuss in later posts.
More importantly, what does this tell us about 2009? The good news for the defense is that there is only one new face in the secondary, converted WR Ray Fisher, who is projected to start at cornerback. Three of last season's opening game starters are back, including safeties Austin Thomas and Nick Polk, who were gone by the Purdue game with season-ending injuries. The linebacking corps is in relatively good shape, with Tyler Replogle moving into a starting role and with Trea Burgess backing him up, but the other 2/3rds of the depth chart is intact. The outside of the D-line returns nearly intact, but there are several new faces in the interior. On offense, the most significant turnover was at WR, with two starters, Andrew Means and Ray Fisher moving on or changing positions. The O-line returns 4 of 5 starters from last season. The RB position will be one of the most interesting. Although starter Marcus Thigpen is in the NFL, Bryan Payton and Demetrius McCray have plenty of experience. Still, I think most Hoosier fans will be disappointed if Darius Willis, who showed so much promise in the spring, remains #3 on the depth chart. Finally, of course, is quarterback, where Ben Chappell, who played often last season, is firmly in control of the QB position.
Again, this isn't IU's official depth chart, and I'm sure it will look much different in late August. But it's a starting point for the ramp-up to football season.
0 recs |
3 comments
|
Comments
It works.
As the note above says, mobile commenting is now live.
The Crimson Quarry, SB Nation's Indiana Hoosiers blog
by John M (The Crimson Quarry) on Jul 8, 2009 9:53 AM EDT via mobile reply actions 0 recs
A couple of questions
And forgive me if I am beating you to something you plan to cover in the next couple of weeks.
1. what ever became of the “Seven Blocks of Limestone”? There was much made a few years ago of the quality OL recruits brought in; yet that seems like it has continued to be a significant weak spot. I admit that I have not followed as closely as I should have. Did I miss something?
2. What are your thoughts on Bryan Payton? I live near Fort Wayne, where he is from. He was not all that heralded coming out of HS, but seemed to show some promise last year. He has written a few things for the local fish wrap this summer, and seems like a pretty articulate kid. Does he have the chops to make an impact in the Big Ten?
Thanks, as always.
by hoosierdaddynow on Jul 9, 2009 12:59 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
I do intend to go into more detail later.
1. The seven blocks of limestone were Pete Saxon, Roger Saffold, James Brewer, Alex Perry, Cody Faulkner, Jarrod Smith, and Mike Stark. Four of the five are projected starters on the OL. Jarrod Smith moved to defense and is expected to be a starting DT. Mike Stark started most of last season at RT, but he may miss 2009 because of injury, so he isn’t in my projected depth chart. Alex Perry, who started 5 games at center last year, missed spring practice with an injury but is supposed to be back this fall. Accordingly, I edited the post and replaced Will Matte with Perry as backup center. I’m sure Perry will see the field somehow, but I’m just guessing as to position. So, individually there aren’t any huge disappointments in the group: all have been starters at some point in their careers. The line wasn’t terribly effective as a unit last year, but there were lots of injuries and position switches during last season. They have the size and the experience, so it’s reasonable to hope for improvement in 2009.
2. Payton has had a solid career thus far, and unless Darius Willis outshines him he will be the starter. Also, he has written a blog since the 2007 season and seems like a smart guy with a future in the sports media if he wants it. He’s averaged over 4.0 per carry in his sophomore and junior seasons.
The Crimson Quarry, SB Nation's Indiana Hoosiers blog
by John M (The Crimson Quarry) on Jul 9, 2009 5:03 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs

by 







