The Crimson Quarry: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Around SBN: The Record of Wrongs: Vanderbilt Commodores

Bill Lynch will be at IU in...2011?

Indiana University athletic director Fred Glass made a strong statement today in support of  football coach Bill Lynch, and said that "of course" Lynch will be back as IU's coach in 2010.  The Indiana Daily Student's characterization of Glass's remarks is that "Lynch will remain in his position as head coach of the IU football program at least until his contract expires in two years," although the Indianapolis Star did not go that far, and the IDS does not directly quote Glass on that point.  Of course, the direct quotes that are in the article are bad enough.  

"He’s in the second year of a four-year contract (that expires after the 2011 season), and like I said last November, contracts need to mean something again at Indiana University."

Fred, it was asinine when you said it last fall, and it's asinine today.  As an attorney, of course you realize that contracts "mean something."  They mean what they say within the four corners of the document.  A coach's employment contract is not an unconditional promise that the coach will be employed through the end of the contract (in Lynch's case, 2011).  It is an agreement that sets forward how much the coach will make while he is employed and establishes various rights and duties of the coach and the university.  Lynch's contract, like nearly all coaching contracts, provides the steps that either the coach or the university must take if either party wants to end the relationship before the contract expires.  It's really bothersome to someone who knows better spout off this Joe Sportsbar nonsense.  Firing a coach before his contract expires is not breaching, breaking, or violating his contract. More:

Star-divide


He mentioned Sports Illustrated’s prediction that IU would win two games total this year and that he believes, but for a few plays, IU could be 6-2 this season. He also does not place the blame for the loss to Northwestern on Lynch.

"There’s been encouraging things and discouraging things," Glass said. "I reject suggestions that that was a loss related to the coaching staff. I don’t agree with that."

Ah, The Sports Illustrated defense.  That one's straight out of the Mike Davis playbook ("what, they picked us to finish eighth because I'm such a lousy coach, and we made the NIT anyway.  What's not to like?").  Sports Illustrated picked IU to finish 2-10 because very people outside of the IU athletic department offices believe that Bill Lynch has much chance to reverse IU's historic fortunes.  SI isn't omiscient.  How could SI know that Akron would be kind enough to remove its starting QB from the team the day before IU played them, or that Ron Zook and his blue-chippers would be entering November without a win over a I-A team?

Yes, we are a few plays away from being 6-2.  We also are a couple of plays away from being 2-6.  Only well-timed turnovers (both forced by the IU defense, but still fortuitous) prevented IU from losing at home to Eastern Kentucky and Western Michigan.  I can see how the historically awful 2008 season may have allowed Glass to forget this, but most teams with bad records don't get blown out in every game.  Bad teams are often competitive but repeatedly fail to play complete games. 

Finally, while I don't expect Glass to air dirty laundry, do the coaches really bear no responsibility for managing to blow a 28-3 lead despite the gift of three second-half interceptions?

This whole affair is frustrating because of the bait-and-switch nature of the Lynch era.  When IU hired Lynch after the 2007 regular season, continuity was a primary rationale.  Lynch would be able to continue the work of the Hoeppner staff, which had been in place since 2005.   It is beyond dispute that in a conventional coaching search, IU never would have considered a coach with Bill Lynch's unimpressive resume.  Now, after Lynch's first  season as  long-term coach yielded one of the worst seasons in school history, and two thirds of the way into what probably will be IU's 14th losing season in 15th years, we are counseled to be patient.  Look, I'll be patient with a coach who is selected after a thoughtful, comprehensive search for the right coach to turn IU from a loser into a winner.  But the only, only, only reason Lynch was hired was because of the percpeption that the program already was on that track.  If Terry Hoeppner's successor was going to be given the standard five years, then IU should have conducted a standard search.  Instead, IU made an emotional hire after an better-than-expected season and expects us to pretend that he was the best man for the job.  He wasn't, he isn't, and were stuck with him for the long haul, it seems.

P.S.  Fred Glass can't really be thinking about forcing Lynch to recruit as a near lame duck, with only two years left on his deal, can he?  Surely he understands the modern landscape of college football better than that.

0 recs  |  Comment 8 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Excellent post, John. While Glass has done a great job of marketing, getting fans involved, and other administrative stuff, I’m fearful that his lack of a background in sports (as in dealing with players and coaches) is going to hurt him. He can’t seriously believe half the things he’s quoted as saying, can he?

by D.M.J. on Oct 28, 2009 2:49 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Well, I guess we've always been at war with Eastasia...

The willful ignorance of reality displayed by our AD is astounding. When is the 2-Minutes Hate scheduled for Purdue?

At least the war is within measurable distance of an end. I love Big Brother.

/English nerd

by LoneStarHoosier on Oct 28, 2009 3:20 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Agree to Disagree

John,
      I disagree. Coach Lynch is the perfect hire for Indiana football. I am just glad Mr. Glass is in charge of running the IU football program and you are just another guy with a blog (albeit a really good blog) Coach Lynch is a solid guy that has great Indiana recruiting ties, has a very diverse resume, and is a man of high character. Your just spouting off because of an emotional loss in Evanston last week. No one was happy with that loss, but it is not his fault that a player can’t gain one yard on 4th and 1. I understand the call of going for it on 4th and 3 when your defense hasn’t been able to stop Northwestern. Who you gonna get John? John Gruden? He isn’t coming to our place. Were you the same guy who was wanting rid of Coach Mallory at the end? How did that work out with Cam? In fact, Coach Mal has gone on the record to state that Coach Lynch is the man for this job. That is just about all the endorsement I need. The man experienced success at Butler and at Ball State before BSU put him in a terrible position in regards to funding. You know what? When Bubba Cunningham let him to go to hire Brady Hoke, Coach Lynch had started to turn the tide back to being respectable again. Bubba fired him and promptly upgraded the facilities and budget. It was not even the same job. Thank God that Mr. Glass has better perspective and vision for our program that your narrow one. We got a real steal with Coach Lynch and the payoff will come. He has already upgraded the program at the skill positions and showing an ability to innovate with the Pistol Offense.

It’s so easy to pile on, so difficult to divorce yourself from your emotions and see things in a pragmatic way.

by Illihooiser on Oct 28, 2009 10:27 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

I agree with much of what you say about Lynch’s character, his recruiting, his willingness to change/innovate on offense, and the hopelessness of the Ball State job when he was there. Still, I think it takes a substantially above average coach to win at IU, and I’m less than convinced that Lynch is that guy. Obviously, he’s going to be here for a while, so I hope I am wrong. Of course, making a chance doesn’t guarantee success. Neither does continuity. Few of the people who make the continuity argument in favor of Lynch argue that IU was wrong to ditch Dinardo after only three years and hire Hep.

The Crimson Quarry, SB Nation's Indiana Hoosiers blog

by John M (The Crimson Quarry) on Oct 29, 2009 8:48 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Fair enough. We shall see. I am still not sure that they are going to give Lynch the chance. I feel that Fred Glass might be just saying that right now to support his coach while the season is going on. For the record, I also felt they didn’t give coach Dinardo enough time. Three years was not enough time for a guy with his resume.

I think we can both agree on this: GO HOOSIERS!!!!

by Illihooiser on Oct 29, 2009 9:31 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Lynch

If you don’t like Lynch, fine, but quit lying about him! His first FULL SEASON as head coach IU went 7-5 in the regular season and went to a bowl game. Hoeppner did not participate in spring practice and passed away before the season. Lynch is 14-19 as IU’s head coach, second only to Mallory’s 68-77 in winning percentage in the last 30 plus years.

by sharksou812 on Oct 29, 2009 5:58 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Why does it matter

where Lynch’s record falls in comparison to other equally awful IU coaches? Losing records should not be acceptable. No one is looking for a BCS bid, but contention for winning seasons should be realistic.

by D.M.J. on Oct 29, 2009 10:19 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Yeah, the 2007 season is on his resume, but he wasn’t hired as the long-term coach until after the 2007 season, just as I said. I made a slight edit to the post to make clear that what I meant was that 2008 was Lynch’s first year as non-interim coach.

As for his record, you are correct, it stands up pretty well in a vacuum. Still, this is pretty similar to his trajectory at Ball State, where his first two years were his best years. In 2.67 seasons, Lynch has 5 wins against teams from the BCS conferences. After three years, Mallory had 6, Cameron had 6, and Dinardo had 4. Hep had 5 in only two seasons. Lynch has a superficially good record, but 5 of his wins have come against the MAC, and 4 have come against I-AA or equivalent team (I am counting 2008 WKU in this group).

The Crimson Quarry, SB Nation's Indiana Hoosiers blog

by John M (The Crimson Quarry) on Oct 30, 2009 7:53 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome. I previously blogged about IU at The Hoosier Report for about two years. You can follow The Crimson Quarry on Twitter. E-mail me at crimsonquarry at sbcglobal.net.
Start posting about the Hoosiers »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
IU Soccer Returns to the Yeagley Family
Small
BOB KNIGHT HAS NO RIGHT!
Small
Mike Freitag, Unplugged
Small
Freitag Era Over at IU
Image-568x758-jpg_small
Big 10 Tour/Indiana Recap Posted!

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managers

Crimson-lg_small John M (The Crimson Quarry)

Official Partner of CBS Sports